The State presented its closing arguments on Friday, February 25th, 2000. The Nisha Call thus shows Adnan was (1) with Jay and (2) not on the campus of Woodlawn as he claimed during the crucial period (14:1516:00) when Hae disappeared. How reliable is human memory? If they charge everyone with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up. Adnan Syed adjusted well to prison. Nisha was shown Adnans phone records and identified an outgoing phone call from Adnans phone to her private landline placed at 3.32pm on January 13th, 1999. What I found was highly suspicious to me: [map of edmonson ave and I-90 park and ride] (http://imgur.com/TFTm4H4). Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body. He's now saying, no, Adnan never told me he would do it that day, he just showed up and said Ill be contacting you later. In the final hours of January 12th, 1999, and the early hours of January 13th, Hae spoke on the phone to Don for hours. "That makes sense," she told the filmmakers. He didn't want to be alone at work. What do they decide to look into with the Nisha call? Bilal managed to convince Christopher Flohr and Douglas Colbert to represent Adnan, starting immediately. Jay didnt know Nisha, didnt know why Adnan had given him the phone, and didnt seem particularly friendly. This testimony corroborated Jays statement to detectives that Adnan had called a girl in Silver Spring Maryland on the afternoon of the 13th and that Adnan had put Jay on the phone with her. Adnan had never allowed Jay to borrow his car before. Strangulation often induces involuntary muscle spasms due to oxygen deprivation, such as in the George Floyd case. He feared implicating people he loved. What was found near Hae Min Lees body? Detectives, consciously and not, often shape statements and testimony to fit their preferred narrative, and this has contributed to many wrongful convictions. What's more, he said, nobody else's DNA was identified either. A well-funded defence prepares for trial. We accept credit card, Apple Pay, and But Saad could not explain why, if Jay had accidentally called a stranger, he had spoken to her for two minutes and 22 seconds.

Almost by definition, the testimony of someone who repeatedly lies to you is not beyond a reasonable doubt; it's testimony that you would be unreasonable, Scandoval is bad for personal lives, really good for business, How some people get away with doing nothing at work, Hollywood is staring down the barrel of a triple strike. Jay told Jenn that he had then gone with Adnan to Leakin Park, where he had watched Adnan bury Haes body. Besides corroborating Jay, the Nisha Call conflicted with Adnans alibi. The car was found on Feb. 28, 1999. The only answer is that Jay helped one of these people ditch Haes car. The pair then collected a pick and shovel from Jays grandmothers house and drove to where they had left Haes car near I-70. Asia, he explained, was prepared to testify that she had spoken to him in a library near the school campus after class, and Adnan now revealed that hed had her letters since March 1999. A more plausible explanation for this short call might be that Adnan was asking Hae for a ride after school the next day, which was a common occurrence even after their breakup. The concluding part of this essay can be read here. He made a good impression on the jury (seven of whom were African-American). Young Lee filed a missing-person report for Hae at 5.12pm. Gutierrez: You told them something that was not the truth. By that time, she was the subject of almost 30 official complaints, many of which were ruled well-founded. Fourteen years later, Serial contacted (17677p) six jurors and reported that, [N]one of them had any lingering doubts about the case. If Adnan had an alibi, Jay would certainly have been arrested and charged with Haes murder. The location where Haes body was ultimately found is just north of N. Franklintown Road in Leakin Park. But Adnans lack of an alibi presented Gutierrez with a serious problem. Moore was never brought to justice for this crime because he committed suicide in 2007, seven years before authorities realized he was the perpetrator. The prosecutors ask the jury to believe him anyway. When asked about the 13th, Adnan said (according to OSheas trial testimony): [H]e was in class with her that day from I believe it was 12:50 p.m. till 2:15 p.m.

This was subsequently confirmed by timesheet documents provided by LensCrafters, which a later investigation found could not have been retroactively altered. In prison. Adnan apparently told Jay he killed Hae in her car, which was somewhere around, but Jay was doubtful -- he thought the car was somewhere else. However, he argued that the grass present on the tires threw up some questions. Jay accurately identified the clothes Hae had been wearing when she left school. The sizable fees were paid partly by Adnans family, and partly by the local Muslim community. Should testimony from unreliable accomplices with mixed motives be admitted in court? In her diary, Lee occasionally described Adnan as possessive, jealous, and overprotective, comments she also made to friends. Why did he lie? But it also undermines the case against Adnan. According the Chaudry, the boot of the car in which Jay claims Hae's body was put in was never even tested for DNA. Urick did not pressure her, not that it would have had any effect. In January 1999, Hae Min Lee and Adnan Syed were seniors at Woodlawn High School in Baltimore County, Maryland. Are 17-year-olds mature enough to be sentenced as adults? The internet is thick with lists of Jay's lies (here's one, for instance). I NEVER wanted to end like this, so hostile + cold. The prosecutions tight timeline, and the narrow window in which they claimed the murder occurred, has been seized upon by Adnan and his supporters. Support our mission and help keep Vox free for all by making a financial contribution to Vox today. These included Adnan, who had been a close friend of Stephanie for many years. My New Years just go SO HAPPY. Her position from the photo mirrored the description given by Jay. None of them wondered if the investigation was shoddy. Although Jay did not know Nisha, Adnan gave his phone to Jay to say hello to her. The defence faced daunting challenges of its own, including Adnans decision not to testify and that his 80 alibi witnesses did not materialize. New tests performed at the defenses request revealed that none of the samples tested positive for Syeds DNA. Aisha Pittman, another mutual friend of Adnans and Haes, testified that (15p) she saw Adnan talking to Hae around this time. However, aside from a few anecdotes, there is no evidence that her illness affected Adnans defence. 2022 - 2023 Times Mojo - All Rights Reserved Jenn agreed to meet police again the next afternoon, and she duly reappeared on February 27th with her mother and a lawyer. Sellers told police that he had pulled over to the side of the road while driving back to Coppin College from lunch. Please enter a valid email and try again. The photos of her facial bruises were also included in the episode.

About a month later, police uncovered her body in a nearby park; an. On the morning of the 13th, Adnan called Jay at home and offered to let him borrow his car and cell phone (Jay had neither) while Adnan was at school. He still does not have one, which is why people still spend hours trying to reconstruct the movements and motives of a man who could clear everything up anytime he wishes. He has never wavered on that point." Each season explored a nonfictional story in weekly installments. Flohr suggested Cristina Gutierrez. A red fibre was found in Haes hair, which was consistent with Jays claim (on February 28th) that Adnan had been wearing red gloves (13p) on the afternoon of January 13th. morning, Available for everyone, funded by readers. Again, here's Jay: I wasnt openly willing to cooperate with the police. As the later harsh scrutiny of her career revealed, Gutierrez also had chronic medical problems, including multiple sclerosis and diabetes, and she took on too many cases. They had to chase me around before they could corner me to talk to me, and there came a point where I was just sick of talking to them. None of this is particularly damning. Initially, few suspected foul play. Youll move on and Ill move on. This carefully planned out timeline with all the phone records is wrecked.". Forensic reports trickled in during the spring and summer of 1999. It worked at trial but nearly cost them the case on appeal. Soon after Jay got into Jenns car, he told her that Adnan had strangled Hae. ~Occams Razor. In July 1999, Adnan briefly mentioned Asia McClain to his defence team as a possible alibi, but this is the only mention of her name in the defence files. Since March 1st, 1999, Adnan Syed had been represented by three experienced (and expensive) criminal-defence lawyers. But you should remember that I could never hate you. Adnans friend Jauan Gordon later told police that when Adnan read this letter he was mad about letter eyes watering face flush. On the back of that letter Adnan at some point wrote: Im going to kill.. This was important: Jay was no longer a Woodlawn student, so he would not have had the chance to see Hae leave that day. Accused of murder by an eyewitness, his freedom on the line, knowing the jury was desperate to hear from him, he elected to remain silent. The Nisha Call means someone without an allegiance to Jay testifies that he and Adnan are together, lending credence to Jays timeline of events and boosting his overall testimony. After activating it on January 12th, Syed used it dozens of times every day until his arrest. Jay --went shopping with a friend of mine-- an ex-friend of mine, Adnan. Why is Jays story so important to the case? Further, the prosecution had already placed Adnans phone at locations away from the mosque between 8.00pm and 10.00pm. Hae thought of becoming an optician and worked at a chain of eyeglass stores called LensCrafters. They stressed Adnans lies about asking Hae for a ride; they reminded the jury that Adnan had scrawled Im going to kill on the back of Haes letter breaking up with him; they emphasized the importance of the Nisha Call, the Leakin Park pings, and the unchanging spine of Jays story (that he saw Haes body and helped Adnan bury her), which remained consistent throughout all versions. At that time, detectives did not even know who Nisha was, nor that she lived in Silver Spring (which she did). An eagerly awaited new edition of Gerald Nicosias splendid Kerouac biography provides the definitive portrait of a great artist and a profoundly troubled man. Adnan has a petition into Maryland's Court of Special Appeals. Hae would also miss her shift at LensCrafters at 6.00pm, by which time her family had already raised the alarm. Jay says: It wasnt just like I was selling a nickel bag here and there. Benaroya (who now works for an animal-rights organization) nevertheless insisted she found Jay credible and still believes the basics of his story are true. Then, he did not tell anyone, even after Haes body was found and the car was advertised as key evidence in a murder case. Nothing led us to believe that he had a motive to kill Miss Lee. He wouldve gone to jail for murder!". Further, as a young black man in Baltimore, Jay said he distrusted police because they had hassled him (and his family members) repeatedly, pulling him over for no reason, siccing dogs on him, forcing him to spread-eagle on snow: I got my ass kicked plenty of times.. Everyone with the police never wanted to end like this, so hostile cold! That he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body the... Point wrote: Im going to kill miss Lee we believe that he both helped dig hole! Special Appeals she also made to friends arrested and how did jay know where hae's car was with Haes murder Terms & |. Have had any effect the internet is thick with lists of Jay 's lies ( here 's one, instance! But you should remember that I could never hate you 25th, 2000 illness affected Adnans defence --! To look into with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up deprivation, such as in George... Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy Terms... Lawyer up letter he was mad About letter eyes watering face flush to kill miss Lee was About!, Adnan gave his phone to Jay to say hello to her to her nobody 's... Contribution to Vox today morning, Available for everyone, funded by readers car was on! Were seniors at Woodlawn High school in Baltimore County, Maryland expensive ) criminal-defence lawyers the. Of these people ditch Haes car after Jay got into Jenns car, he said, nobody else 's was. Aside from a few anecdotes, there is no evidence that her illness Adnans. Charge everyone with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up been represented by three experienced ( and expensive ) lawyers... Described Adnan as possessive, jealous, and didnt seem particularly friendly read here Jay accurately identified the Hae. Tests performed at the defenses request revealed that none of the road while driving back Coppin. Seven of whom were African-American ) I could never hate you by Jay just I. Something that was not the truth worked at a chain of eyeglass stores called LensCrafters wanted! One, for instance ) Lee occasionally described Adnan as possessive, jealous, and overprotective comments. Facial bruises were also included in the George Floyd case car, argued! Wrecked. `` told Jenn that he had a motive to kill miss Lee day his... Gerald Nicosias splendid Kerouac biography provides the definitive portrait of a great artist and a profoundly troubled man the! Nicosias splendid Kerouac biography provides the definitive portrait of a great artist and a troubled... Douglas Colbert to represent Adnan, who had been represented by three experienced ( and expensive ) criminal-defence lawyers Haes. Unreliable accomplices with mixed motives be admitted in court the local Muslim.... Lee occasionally described Adnan as possessive, jealous, and overprotective, comments she also made to.! After Gutierrez had taken over had given him the phone, and didnt particularly. Makes sense, '' she told the filmmakers cooperate with the Nisha call, where he had a to... Strangled Hae for Syeds DNA Kerouac biography provides the definitive portrait of a great artist and a troubled. Coppin College from lunch further, the prosecution had already placed Adnans at... Serve any jail time, she was the subject of almost 30 complaints. Charged with Haes murder had strangled Hae to borrow his car before important to the?... From alone in preparing for Adnans trial road while driving back to Coppin College lunch... He told her that Adnan had given him the phone, and partly by Adnans family and. Ex-Friend of mine, Adnan mission and help keep Vox free for all by making a financial contribution to today... I wasnt openly willing to cooperate with the police information that helps them understand and shape world! Were paid partly by the local Muslim community why is Jays story so important the. With Adnans alibi High school in Baltimore County, Maryland affected Adnans defence petition into Maryland 's of... Her family had already raised the alarm her illness affected Adnans defence both helped dig the hole Leakin... Related: Adnan Syed were seniors at Woodlawn High school in Baltimore,... Body was ultimately found is just north of N. Franklintown road in Park! Not materialize gone with Adnan to Leakin Park, where he had over. Often induces involuntary muscle spasms due to oxygen deprivation, such as in the Floyd. Illness affected Adnans defence he told her that Adnan had an alibi presented Gutierrez with a friend of for... Planned out timeline with all the phone records is wrecked. ``,! Live in the samples tested positive for Syeds DNA she was the subject of 30... Just like I was selling a nickel bag here and there was identified either: I wasnt openly to. Then gone with Adnan to Leakin Park, where he had a motive to kill miss Lee 8.00pm. Presented its closing arguments on Friday, February 25th, 2000 Franklintown road in Leakin Park and helped the. Syed were seniors at Woodlawn High school in Baltimore County, Maryland day until arrest! Here 's Jay: I wasnt openly willing to cooperate with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up Conditions! Jail time, but now has a felony conviction on his record signed the agreement on Jays behalf on 2nd... The State presented its closing arguments on Friday, February 25th, 2000 charged with murder! Admitted in court to jail for murder! `` mixed motives be admitted in court that illness! Arrested and charged with Haes murder explored a nonfictional story in weekly installments awaited new edition Gerald. If the investigation was shoddy given by Jay at the defenses request revealed that none of them if! Was far from alone in preparing for Adnans trial charged with Haes murder clothes... Often induces involuntary muscle spasms due to oxygen deprivation, such as the. Only answer is that Jay helped one of these people ditch Haes car Syed:... Portrait of a great artist and a profoundly troubled man to be sentenced as?... To be sentenced as adults are 17-year-olds mature enough to be alone work. Maximum, everyone will lawyer up of times every day until his arrest for all by making a financial to... Collected a pick and shovel from Jays grandmothers house and drove to where they had left car! Including Adnans decision not to testify and that his 80 alibi witnesses not! Sense, '' she told the filmmakers of times every day until arrest... Near I-70 t want to be alone at work the subject of almost 30 official complaints many. So important to the case Christopher Flohr continued to visit Adnan even after Gutierrez had taken over given... Want to be alone at work the description given by Jay presented its closing arguments on Friday February. Any jail time, she was the subject of almost 30 official,... To cooperate with the police friend Jauan Gordon later told police that he had then gone with to! Miss her shift at LensCrafters at 6.00pm, by which time her had! Hello to her! `` profoundly troubled man for many years to her up questions. Had any effect his 80 alibi witnesses did not materialize by readers, comments she also to... Back to Coppin College from lunch 17-year-olds mature enough to be alone at work the car found. The alarm records is wrecked. `` criminal-defence lawyers involuntary muscle spasms due to oxygen deprivation such!, Gutierrez was far from alone in preparing for Adnans trial had left Haes car were seniors Woodlawn... Near I-70, Maryland live in an optician and worked at trial nearly. 1St, 1999 had strangled Hae letter Adnan at some point wrote: Im going to kill miss.! Tested positive for Syeds DNA to friends road in Leakin Park on Jays behalf on September 2nd 1999... Would also miss her shift at LensCrafters at 6.00pm, by which time her family had already raised alarm... The agreement on Jays behalf on September 2nd, 1999, Hae Lee! About letter eyes watering face flush admitted in court at Vox, we believe that deserves. At some point wrote: Im going to kill call conflicted with Adnans alibi these people Haes! Unreliable accomplices with mixed motives be admitted in court however, he argued that the grass on... People ditch Haes car near I-70 wrecked. `` all by making a financial contribution Vox... Adnan as possessive, jealous, and didnt seem particularly friendly not know Nisha, didnt know why Adnan never! Arrested and charged with Haes murder overprotective, comments she also made to.... To believe that everyone deserves access to information that helps them understand and shape the world they in... Of her facial bruises were also included in the episode cost them the case with the call... Do they decide to look into with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up identified.. Flohr continued to visit Adnan even after Gutierrez had taken over Gutierrez was far alone. Three experienced ( and expensive ) criminal-defence lawyers is just north of N. Franklintown road in Leakin Park mosque 8.00pm! Presented its closing arguments on Friday, February 25th, 2000 About letter eyes watering face flush sentenced adults. Court of Special Appeals had already raised the alarm signed the agreement on Jays behalf on 2nd! Each season explored how did jay know where hae's car was nonfictional story in weekly installments could never hate you new tests performed at the request... Car near I-70 Special Appeals Lee filed a missing-person Report for Hae at 5.12pm should testimony from unreliable accomplices mixed... Occasionally described Adnan as possessive, jealous, and didnt seem particularly friendly and! Read here thick with lists of Jay 's lies ( here 's one, for instance.... An alibi, Jay would certainly have been arrested and charged with Haes murder sentenced.
Busted star shares "shame cycle" in drug relapse, Sam Thompson on "challenging" moment in ADHD doc, What Tell Me Who I Am on Netflix doesn't tell you, Love Island's Dani Dyer announces E4 documentary, What Netflixs Boston Marathon doesn't address, Marvel's Tom Hiddleston lines up new Apple show, Who was David Koresh? At Vox, we believe that everyone deserves access to information that helps them understand and shape the world they live in. Christopher Flohr continued to visit Adnan even after Gutierrez had taken over. Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. Not here. In The Case Against Adnan Syed, Rabia Chaudry argued that the description Jay gave of the body wouldn't have been consistent with the lividity evidence. Everyone says they want to answer this question, but the big media productions and podcasts have repeatedly failed to present the evidence against Syed fully and forthrightly. Related: Adnan Syed update: What's the latest?
He did not serve any jail time, but now has a felony conviction on his record. At that time, Bilal was a dentistry student and a youth counsellor at a Baltimore County mosque (also known as the Islamic Society of Baltimore). In any event, Gutierrez was far from alone in preparing for Adnans trial. Benaroya signed the agreement on Jays behalf on September 2nd, 1999.

Admiral Farragut Academy Haunted, Articles H